CEDAR RAPIDS — Some circumstances involving DNA come right down to a battle of the specialists, however a protection DNA skilled testifying for Matthew Robbins, accused of robbing and fatally capturing of James Booher in 2014, agreed with the prosecution’s specialists.
Michael Spence, forensic DNA advisor and proprietor of Spence Forensic Assets in Las Cruces, N.M., on Thursday agreed with the findings of the prosecution’s DNA forensic examiner or a state crime lab analysts, barely refining two outcomes.
He agreed with Charity Davis, an FBI nuclear forensic examiner on the FBI Lab in Quantico, Va., who testified Tuesday, that there have been two DNA contributors to the bone fragments.
Spence discovered one contributor was a feminine. In her testimony, Davis mentioned she couldn’t utterly rule out that one might be a feminine however that one was positively a male.
Robbins is accused of robbing and killing Booher, a drug seller, Could 31, 2014. He’s charged with theft affecting interstate commerce, conspiracy to commit theft affecting interstate commerce, and utilizing, carrying and brandishing a firearm throughout against the law of violence leading to homicide.
The protection wrapped up its case in U.S. District Court docket on Thursday morning with out Robbins testifying.
U.S. District Chief Decide Leonard Strand on Thursday knowledgeable Robbins of his proper to testify. Robbins mentioned he understood, and it was his selection to not testify.
Robbins already is serving a 10-year federal jail sentence for being a felon and an illegal drug consumer. He was convicted in 2015.
Closing arguments in his trial had been Thursday afternoon, with the jury to start deliberations Friday morning. If convicted, Robbins faces a compulsory 10 yr sentence and as much as life in federal jail.
In final week’s testimony, multiple witness mentioned Robbins fatally shot Booher with a sawed-off shotgun and burned his physique in a burn pit in again of the farmhouse.
One witness was Robbins’ former girlfriend, Danielle Busch, who has been convicted in the case, and was at the house when the alleged killing happened. Others testified Robbins had confessed to them.
Spence, the New Mexico DNA skilled, on Thursday mentioned he didn’t have plenty of expertise analyzing human stays however had reviewed a webinar this yr on eradicating DNA from bones for testing.
He additionally agreed with Davis and Tara Scott, an Iowa Division of Prison Investigation criminalist, that it was Booher’s DNA discovered on partitions, a vent cowl and a glove at Robbins’ home.
The within of the glove had DNA from 4 people — female and male — and Booher was excluded because the contributor.
He additionally concurred with Scott that stains taken from the farmhouse’s entrance door and curtains confirmed two unknown male DNA profiles, and that not one of the profiles developed matched Robbins.
In different testimony, Jeff Voshell of Cedar Rapids, mentioned he has been good pals with Robbins since they had been 14- or 15-years-old. Robbins had finished some carpentry work for him and he used to “hang around” at Robbins’ dwelling in Ely. He was on the market a number of weeks earlier than Could 14, 2014, he mentioned.
On cross-examination, Voshell denied seeing Robbins, a meth consumer, use medication and didn’t know he had been convicted on firearms and drug expenses.
Assistant U.S. Legal professional Lisa Williams famous Voshell visited Robbins in jail and gave him cash, however Robbins hid issues from him?
Voshell mentioned he didn’t consider it that approach, saying he understood there are issues an individual won’t need others to know.
Noah Cripe, previously of Cedar Rapids and now residing in Wyoming, mentioned Robbins, his finest buddy, came around him when he was working in Lansing, Mich., in June 2014. Robbins was “doing what he shouldn’t have been doing” — utilizing meth — and he came around as a result of Cripe had his “stuff collectively.”
Feedback: (319) 398-8318; trish.mehaffey@thegazette.com
