Veronica Escobar: “We started seeing the rise in unaccompanied minors going again to final April 2020. This isn’t one thing that occurred because of Joe Biden turning into president.”
PolitiFact’s ruling: Half True
Here is why: U.S. Rep. Veronica Escobar, D-El Paso, joined CNN host Jake Tapper on March 14 to defend President Joe Biden’s response to the inflow of unaccompanied youngsters on the southern border and shift blame to the Trump administration.
The variety of unaccompanied youngsters encountered by Border Patrol elevated sharply earlier this 12 months, from 5,858 in January to 9,457 in February — a 61% improve, in line with federal information. It’s the most important one month proportion improve since U.S. Customs and Border Safety started reporting the information in 2010.
“Is that this a disaster?” Tapper requested Escobar.
“There isn’t any doubt, Jake, that what we’re seeing right now is a gigantic problem,” Escobar replied, including that the uptick is a consequence of the Trump administration’s immigration insurance policies that the Biden administration is “is working day and evening” to amend.
Extra:Vice President Kamala Harris to lead White House efforts to stem migration at the border
“We started seeing the rise in unaccompanied minors going again to final April 2020. This isn’t one thing that occurred because of Joe Biden turning into president,” Escobar mentioned. “We noticed the will increase courting again nearly a 12 months. And this was throughout the Trump administration.”
The rising variety of folks arriving on the U.S.-Mexico border has change into a partisan subject — Democrats blaming the uptick on Trump insurance policies whereas Republicans blame it on modifications the Biden administration has applied.
Throughout a March 21 interview on ABC Information, Division of Homeland Safety Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas made feedback just like Escobar’s.
“Why is it particularly difficult and troublesome now? As a result of the whole system underneath United States regulation that has been in place all through administrations of each events was dismantled in its entirety by the Trump administration,” Mayorkas mentioned.
Gov. Greg Abbott, however, has blamed Biden’s “reckless open border insurance policies” for the “surge in border crossings and cartel exercise.”
Migration patterns are advanced and pushed by quite a few components past modifications in U.S. immigration coverage, consultants say. Is Escobar correct in saying that will increase within the variety of unaccompanied minors arriving on the border dates again to the Trump administration? And is she appropriate to say that these will increase aren’t “a results of Joe Biden turning into president”?
Unaccompanied minors in 2020
The primary a part of Escobar’s assertion is correct — the variety of unaccompanied minors encountered on the border has been rising since April 2020. However this pattern typically follows seasonal migration patterns. Migration numbers sometimes peak within the spring, often in Could, and reduce within the late summer season.
However in 2020, the regular rise continued by way of the winter. In keeping with Artwork Arthur, a former immigration choose and a fellow at the Heart for Immigration Research, a think-tank that advocates for low immigration numbers, the regular rise in migrants by way of June, July and August is a “reversion to the imply.”
Migration numbers throughout the board “fell off a cliff” in late March 2020 after the Trump administration activated Title 42, a provision of the 1944 Public Well being and Security Act that permits Border Patrol to expel any migrant for well being and security causes, on this case to restrict the unfold of COVID-19 into the U.S. Since migration numbers bottomed out in April 2020 due to Title 42, the will increase in migrant numbers all through the the rest of 2020 returned month-to-month totals nearer to common ranges, Arthur mentioned.
Extra:Texas Gov. Abbott: Migrant children at border are vulnerable to sex traffickers
However that regular rise modified in February, when U.S. Customs and Border Safety reported the 61% uptick.
“We’re seeing a reversion to the imply because it pertains to unaccompanied youngsters, however we noticed an enormous spike (in February 2021), and it’s a much bigger spike than we’ve seen in any February ever,” Arthur mentioned.
That uptick occurred in the same month the Biden administration suspended Title 42 for unaccompanied children only, leaving it in place for all other categories of apprehended migrants, much to the chagrin of immigrant advocates.
In late January, after a federal appeals court ruled that the federal government could use Title 42 to expel unaccompanied minors, the White House announced that, unlike under the Trump administration, it would no longer apply Title 42 to children crossing the border alone.
The uptick in unaccompanied minors was recorded soon after that announcement. And as of March 23, there were 4,962 children in Customs and Border Patrol custody, well above the 30-day average of 3,243, according to NBC News.
“I can’t determine a single different issue that may level to that,” Arthur mentioned. “There’s no different variable apart from that.”
Push vs. pull components
Whereas Arthur highlights the White Home’s coverage change as a pull issue that was a major driver behind February’s uptick, different consultants underscore the push components driving migrants out of their origin international locations.
Migrants and migrant youngsters journey from their origin international locations — primarily Mexico, Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador — to the southern U.S. border for a mess of causes: worsened financial circumstances as a result of COVID-19, cartel violence, corruption, pure disasters, agricultural illnesses or droughts and, amongst others, the vagaries of U.S help. These points have factored into folks’s migration selections for many years.
One such push issue challenged the Central America area in November, when two category-4 hurricanes struck Nicaragua, Honduras and Guatemala inside a two-week span. Greater than 200 folks have been killed, and hundreds of thousands have been left in want of help. The hurricanes exacerbated poverty and worsened entry to scrub water, giving an additional nudge to folks contemplating northern migration.
“There are clearly push components popping out of all these international locations, no matter what our insurance policies are,” mentioned Ruth Wasem, a professor of public coverage on the College of Texas. And it’s arduous to say that pull components created by liberalized U.S. immigration insurance policies are stronger than the push components driving migrants away from their origin international locations, she mentioned.
For subscribers:How a Brownsville Democrat’s retirement, the migrant surge and new political maps leave South Texas vulnerable to GOP takeover
To Wasem, it’s no shock border authorities are reporting excessive numbers of unaccompanied minors after 4 years of austere immigration insurance policies underneath the Trump administration, which revamped the asylum-seeking processes in many ways that lowered the variety of asylum seekers coming into the U.S.
However the close to closure of the U.S.-Mexico border underneath Trump doesn’t imply that migrants stopped packing their luggage for the U.S.
“Trump mainly shut down our immigration system and ended the legal guidelines on the books,” Wasem mentioned. “So there’s going to be a pent-up variety of folks that have been ready to return, or that have been en route.”
Wasem factors to information from the Mexican Fee for Refugee Help, a Mexican federal company that processes refugee-status purposes. Beneath Trump administration policies, asylum seekers have been required to use for asylum and be denied in one of many international locations they handed by way of earlier than in search of asylum within the U.S.
In keeping with the information, month-to-month utility numbers ebbed and flowed previous to Biden’s coverage modifications, exhibiting that push components in origin international locations are a serious driver behind migrant and unaccompanied youngsters in search of to enter the U.S., Wasem mentioned.
“Unaccompanied youngsters coming to the U.S. is a results of what is going on on within the international locations they’re coming from,” she mentioned. “How we reply to them modifications from administration to administration. So when Escobar says the rise in unaccompanied youngsters did not occur because of Biden, I’d say the ebb and circulate is not a results of who’s within the White Home.”
That logic is echoed by different immigration researchers. Writing for the Washington Post, Director of the U.S. Immigration Coverage Heart Tom Wong and College of California at San Diego researchers say that the most recent spike is attributable to a migration backlog.
“The present improve in apprehensions suits a predictable sample of seasonal modifications in undocumented immigration mixed with a backlog of demand due to 2020’s coronavirus border closure,” they wrote of their evaluation of federal immigration information.
Lengthy-term federal information means that “Title 42 expulsions delayed potential migrants moderately than deterred them — they usually’re arriving now,” they wrote.
The Biden issue
There’s little doubt that migrants, and younger youngsters particularly, are being despatched throughout the border impressed by Biden’s new immigration insurance policies. However Wasem says that the hope Biden administration insurance policies have impressed in migrants is arduous to measure.
“Are folks coming as a result of the considered Biden’s presidency provides them hope? That could be. However you’ll be able to’t measure that,” she mentioned.
One 9-year-old boy, as an illustration, traveled on foot for over a month by way of Mexico from Honduras aiming to attach with a member of the family in Florida. He was found by Border Patrol within the Rio Grande Valley and advised one ABC Information reporter that his mom had despatched him as a result of she had heard that immigration authorities have been turning households away, however not youngsters.
Biden himself has acknowledged that whereas his administration has drawn the eye of migrant households, his extra humanitarian insurance policies can’t be the one issue compelling households to ship their youngsters on the perilous northward journey. Lots of the push components cited by Wasem — like worsening poverty or gang violence — are additionally factoring into the calculus of migrants.
“That (9-year-old boy’s) mom didn’t sit round on the kitchen desk and say, ‘I acquired an important thought. The way in which I’m going to ensure my son will get taken care of is I’m going to ship him on a ten,000-mile journey by way of the desert into the U.S. as a result of I do know Joe Biden’s a pleasant man and he’ll care for him,’” Biden mentioned. “What a determined act to need to take. Circumstances should be horrible.”
Our ruling
Escobar, whose workplace didn’t reply to requests for remark, mentioned that will increase in the variety of unaccompanied minors reaching the southern U.S. border have been rising since April 2020, when Trump was president.
It’s correct to say that the variety of youngsters touring alone to the border has been rising since final April, however her assertion downplays the truth that February noticed a document improve in unaccompanied minors encountered by Border Patrol brokers.
Escobar additionally mentioned that these will increase are not “a results of Joe Biden turning into president.” Specialists say that the pull issue created by Biden’s coverage change to cease expulsions of the minorsis one in all a number of components driving the uptick in unaccompanied minors. Nevertheless, there’s dispute over whether or not this pull issue is a extra major driver than different push components.
We charge this declare Half True.
Sources
CNN, Dem Congresswoman: ‘Unacceptable’ border surge is ‘enormous challenge’, March 14, 2021
U.S. Customs and Border Safety, Southwest Land Border Encounters, March 10, 2021
U.S. Customs and Border Safety, United States Border Patrol Total Unaccompanied Alien Children (0-17 Years Old) Apprehensions By Month, 2010-2019
ABC Information, ‘This Week’ Transcript 3-21-21: Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, Gov. Doug Ducey, Rep. Michael McCaul, Rep. Judy Chu, March 21, 2021
Telephone interview with Artwork Arthur, resident fellow in regulation and coverage on the Heart for Immigration Research, March 23, 2021
Bipartisan Coverage Heart, How the Trump Administration is Using COVID-19 to Continue its Border Deterrence Efforts, Could 21, 2020
NBC Information, Fact checking Biden on migrant surge during first news conference, March 25, 2021
Telephone interview with Dr. Ruth Wasem, Professor of Public Coverage Follow on the College of Texas LBJ College of Public Affairs, March 23, 2021
Vox, Migrants are heading north because Central America never recovered from last year’s hurricanes, March 22, 2021
PolitiFact, Fact-checking claim about Trump administration changes to the immigration system, March 24, 2021
Nationwide Immigration Discussion board, Mexico’s Asylum System Is Inadequate, Oct. 28, 2019
Refugee standing recognition purposes, Mexican Fee for Refugee Help, accessed March 24, 2021
ABC Information, Scared and hungry: Young boys cross the border alone, March 25, 2021
CNN, Watch Biden’s first formal press conference, March 25, 2021
Washington Put up, The migrant ‘surge’ at the U.S. southern border is actually a predictable pattern, March 25, 2021
Pew Analysis Heart, Migrant apprehensions at U.S.-Mexico border are surging again, March 15, 2021
